Engaged Dharma Insight Group (EDIG)

Pragmatism, Pluralism and Practice

Menu

Skip to content
  • About EDIG
    • Lineage
    • The Teachers
  • EDIG MARKETPLACE
    • Encompassing Directions: Sigalovada Sutta
    • Pragmatic Buddhism: Reflecting Contemporary Vitality
    • Lucky Buddha Beer – Artistic Creative Re-Description
  • BUDDHIST TOOLBOX
    • The Arising of Meditation
    • Dharma of the Individual
    • Dukkha (Suffering) as Human Experience
    • ‘Freedom’ of Choice
    • Friendship
    • The Language of Pluralism
    • Mind in a New Moment — Engaging Beginner’s Mind
    • Patience is a Virtue – Perfection of Acceptance
    • Practice Skill-In-Means
    • Strangers — Form and Emptiness
  • MEDIA REVIEWS – Books and more
    • Buddha and the Terrorist
    • Breakfast with Buddha
    • Encyclopedia of Buddhism
    • Living with the Devil: A Meditation on Good and Evil, Stephen Batchelor
    • Snow Leopard
    • Walking the Tiger’s Path
    • What Makes You Not A Buddhist
    • Why I Am A Buddhist
  • INTENTIONAL PRACTICE
    • AGGRESSION IN MANY FORMS
    • Art of Renewing Vows
    • Gassho: The Mudra Of Coming Together
    • JUMP IN . . . THE WATER’S . . . WHAT WE MAKE IT
    • Lighten Up
    • Meaning Of Buddhist Altar Elements & Ritual Practice
    • Not-Self
    • Reciting the Three Refuges as Intentional Practice
    • Samsara As Seen By The Four Schools Of Zen, And The Path Out
    • Setting Up a Buddhist Altar & Sacred Space
    • The Eightfold Path: Willingness and Experience
  • JATAKA TALES AND PARABLES
    • A Squirrel and the Dharma: Pragmatism in Buddhism
    • Be Patient, Experience: Parable of the White Hat
    • MAYBE THE 8.5 FOLD PATH? A FUTURE JATAKA TALE
    • Rock in the Road – Uncovering Buddha-element
    • Suffering Calf — Future Buddha Jataka Tale
    • Vessantara, the Charitable Prince: Thinking Differently
    • World-View Buffet: A Contemporary Parable
  • PLACES OF INTEREST
    • Mid-America Buddhist Association: Augusta, Missouri
    • SHAMBHALA IN COLORADO
    • WELCOMED AT TARA MANDALA, PAGOSA SPRINGS, CO
  • Sutra & Dharma Seeds
    • Acintita Sutta: Content in Not-Knowing
    • Alagaddupama Sutra: The Water Snake
    • Candala Sutta: Fully Realized Disciple
    • Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta: 1st Turning
    • Diamond Sutra
    • Don’t Be An Ass — The Gadrabha Sutta
    • Eight Realizations
    • From the Master’s Cushion: Being Buddhist
    • Heart Sutra
    • THREE CHARACTERISTICS OF EXISTENCE: PRACTICE
    • Vimalakirti Sutra: Art of a Bodhisattva
  • THOUGHT FARM
    • Pure Buddhism. No Such Thing.
    • All Phenomena is Causally Conditioned . . . Even You
    • Buddha Is Not Dharma
    • Buddhism and a Secular Path – Part One
      • Buddhism and a Secular Path – Part Two
      • Buddhism and a Secular Path – Part Three
      • Buddhism and a Secular Path – Part 4
      • Buddhism and a Secular Path – Part V
    • Eat Your Vegetables, or Meat, Your Choice
    • Honor ALL Living Beings – Carnivore, Herbivore, Omnivore
    • Buddhists Wear Clothes
    • Moments and Causality
    • RIGHT VIEW: INDIVIDUALITY PARADOX – Part One
      • RIGHT MINDFULNESS: INDIVIDUALITY PARADOX Part Two
    • Sokei-An and Realizing Buddhism
    • Who are you competing with?

american presidential race

Truth-Claims

January 6, 2016January 6, 2016engageddharma Leave a comment

By Wayne Ren-Cheng

 

In the first chapter of his previous book, ‘Confessions of a Buddhist Atheist’ Stephen Batchelor describes his own arising and falling away of a lie he recounted to himself and others and the effect it had on his view of Buddhist philosophy and practice. In his recent book, ‘Before Buddhism’, he offers the term truth-claim. It serves as a skillful way to describe an activity that many people resort to in religious, social and political arenas.

It is a fact of human psychology that if you tell yourself the same story over-and-over that it can become the “truth” in your mind. The same is a fact if someone like a politician, fortune teller, religious figure or parent tells you the same thing repeatedly that it can become the “truth” in your mind. This is how truth-claims arise.

In the book, ‘The Moor’s Account’ by Laila Lalami, a Moroccan slave named Estebancio experiences the words and actions of Catholic priests claiming that all the Native Americans in Florida were converted to Christianity because prayers had been said over a deserted village. He wrote in his journal that these priests were attempting to create truth by what they said . . . making truth-claims . . . rather than speaking the truth.

A current example of truth-claiming is happening in the presidential race in the United States. While all the politicians involved are engaging in this practice, one stands out from all the rest. Donald Trump making statements about Mexican and Syrian refuges labeling them as dangerous to Americans, that he will make Mexico pay for a wall, and that thousands of Muslims in New Jersey cheered the death and destruction that took place on 9/11 are efforts to create truth rather than speak the truth. Trump speaks to both create ‘truth’ and to strengthen the truth-claims of those desperate to hold on to their own created truths.

In the Udana Sutta (6:4) the Buddha found himself in the middle of dispute concerning belief in rebirth. A large group consisting of contemplatives, brahmans and other religious wanderers from various sects were offering their different views, opinions, and beliefs. The sutta describes their views “The cosmos is eternal. Only this is true; anything otherwise is worthless. Some of the contemplatives & brahmans held this doctrine, this view: “The cosmos is eternal. Only this is true; anything otherwise is worthless. The cosmos is not eternal” … “The cosmos is finite” … “The cosmos is infinite” … “The soul is the same thing as the body” … “The soul is one thing and the body another” … “After death a Tathagata exists” … “After death a Tathagata does not exist” … “After death a Tathagata both exists & does not exist” … “After death a Tathagata neither exists nor does not exist. Only this is true; anything otherwise is worthless.” The arguments continued for a time eventually degrading into each one announcing about their own view, “The dharma is like this, it’s not like that. The dharma’s not like that, it’s like this.”

The Buddha offered the parable of the blind and the elephant. The King of Savatthi, faced with a similar situation had brought together a group of people blind from birth and them “see” an elephant. Afterwards he came to them and asked if they had “seen” the elephant, to which they answered yes. The King asked them to describe it. “The blind people who had been shown the elephant’s head said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like a jar.’ “Those who had been shown the elephant’s ear said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like a winnowing basket.’ “Those who had been shown the elephant’s tusk said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like plowshare.’1 “Those who had been shown the elephant’s trunk said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like the pole of a plow.’ “Those who had been shown the elephant’s body said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like a granary.’ “Those who had been shown the elephant’s foot said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like a post.’ “Those who had been shown the elephant’s hindquarters said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like a mortar.’ “Those who had been shown the elephant’s tail said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like a pestle.’ “Those who had been shown the tuft at the end of the elephant’s tail said, ‘The elephant, your majesty, is just like a broom.’ “Saying, ‘The elephant is like this, it’s not like that. The elephant’s not like

that, it’s like this,’ they struck one another with their fists.

Each person who had touched the elephant was defending a truth-claim. This very thing happens between Buddhist traditions and practitioners. A moral of the Parable of the Blind and the Elephant is that the dharma must not be viewed as a set of truth-claims as this will only lead to conflict between truth-claims. Letting go of attachment to truth-claims will the knowledge arise that dharma practice isn’t about being “right or wrong”. Basing behavior and belief on metaphysical (things we can’t prove through our own experience) truth-claims is not what the Buddha envisioned. He offered tasks one could engage in, and principles and values so a practitioner could use them as guides so that each situation could be viewed as unique and be responded to appropriately. Each all instances a practitioner must ask, “What is the wisest and most compassionate thing to do?” In the language of Engaged Dharma, “What will promote human flourishing on the most encompassing scale?”

There is another important aspect to an effect of Mr. Batchelor’s Tibetan experience. It became the cause of his atheist view of Buddhism, a complete discounting of metaphysical and deific doctrine across Buddhist traditions. The Buddha set aside metaphysical as ‘I don’t know’ or ‘it hasn’t been proven to me’, so those theories were not critical to a moment-to-moment Buddhist practice. The Buddha did not deny their existence, only their value without proof through experience. For this reason I disagree with Mr. Batchelor, accepting an agnostic, ‘be open to accept proof’, over an atheistic view. That doesn’t hold for Buddhism as a ‘deific doctrine’ because the Buddha made it clear that he was no deity only a human being, and he proclaimed in the moments before his death (Maha Parinibbana Sutta), “It may be, Ananda, that to some among you the thought will come: ‘Ended is the word of the Master; we have a Master no longer.’ But it should not, Ananda, be so considered. For that which I have proclaimed and made known as the Dhamma and the Discipline, that shall be your Master when I am gone.”

The Buddha was both pragmatic and non-dogmatic. He offered the dharma not as any ‘truth’. He offered the dharma as reality that each of us must strive to experience beyond our own perceptions, preferences, habits and dispositions – our habitual reactivity. There he knew, from his own experience that each of us would experience nirvana in our moment-to-moment living.

The EDIG sangha at the Buddha Center in Second Life is a non-denominational one; a sangha open to, and attended by Buddhists of a mix of traditions and non-Buddhists. On occasion someone will voice a truth-claim they read in a book or heard from another teacher. Some are trying to assert what they believe to be ‘truth’, while others are offering a ‘truth’ more to ask if there is truth to what they know, and a few are attempting to actively defend what they hope is ‘truth’. In all instances they hear that if their ‘truth’ works for them in their pursuit of positive personal character and human flourishing then they should hold to that reality; if not then they must look to the Dharma and their own experience so that a more appropriate reality can arise.

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest
  • Pocket
  • Reddit
  • Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

SEARCH FOR INSIGHT

FOLLOW EDIG ON INSTAGRAM @ engageddharma_virtualbuddhism

THE HEART SUTRA

Avalokitesvara, Bodhisattva of compassion, observing deeply the refinement of wisdom, Prajnaparamita, clearly saw the emptiness of personality, thus enduring adversity and pain.

O, Saripurtra, form is no other than emptiness, emptiness no other than form; form is exactly emptiness, emptiness exactly form, the same is true of feeling, perception, mental formations and consciousness.

O, Saripurtra, all dharmas are forms of emptiness, not born, not destroyed; not tainted, not pure, not increasing, not decreasing, and so in emptiness there is no form, no feeling, no perception, no mental formations, no consciousness; no eyes, no ears, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind; no color, no sound, so smell, no taste, no touch, no thought, no realm of sight and so forth until no realm of consciousness, no ignorance, no end to ignorance and so forth until no old age and death, and no end to old age and death, no suffering, no desire, no cessation, no path, no wisdom, no attainment.

And so the Bodhisattva relies on the Prajnaparamita with no hindrance in the mind, no hindrance, therefore no fear, far beyond deluded thoughts, this is Nirvana.

All past, present, and future Buddhas rely on the refinement of wisdom and thus attain the cultivated enlightenment.

Therefore, know that the Prajnaparamita is the interdependent mantra, the interconnected mantra, the mantra of world making the mantra which relieves all suffering.

So proclaim the Prajnaparamita mantra, proclaim the mantra and say: Gate! Gate! Paragate! Parasamgate! Bodhi Sva Ha!

Great refinement of wisdom, Prajnaparamita, Heart Sutra!

Rev. David Xi-Ken Astor and Wayne Ren-Cheng Shi

Zen Buddhist Monks

The Teachers

Rev. David – Jim Yong-Xiang Eubanks Sensei – Wayne Shi

Ven. David (Xi-Ken) -- Eubanks Sensei (Shi Yong Xiang) -- Ven. Wayne (Ren-Cheng)

EXPERIENCE THE ARTICLES OF THE PAST

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 408 other followers

We are each unique expressions of the universe. We are not each unique in the universe.

Blogs for Insight

  • www.gpgrieve.org/index.php/feed
  • DHARMA WINDS ZEN HERMITAGE - (DWZH)
  • Shambhala Online
  • The Buddha Center
  • Order of Engaged Buddhists
  • Buddhism now

Wayne Ren-Cheng Shi’s avatar VenerableWayne Slacker in the Deer Park at the Buddha Center

The Buddha Center in the virtual world of Second Life is a non-denominational Buddhist resource where all are welcome.  I, Wayne Ren-Cheng am in my eighth year offering the dharma in this beautiful, peaceful space.  The EDIG/BC sangha invites you to join us Fridays at 2pm Second Life Time (SLT is U.S. Western Time Zone) and Mondays at 11am SLT.

Main temple at the Buddha Center in the virtual world of Second Life

Inside the main temple

2011 Sangha in the main temple at the Buddha Center

EDIG sangha in the early days of the Buddha Center.

The Deer Park

Place of Peace Temple a Japanese Temple on the grounds of Furman University, South Carolina

THE THREE REFUGES:

I go for refuge to the Buddha, the teacher

I go for refuge to the Dharma, the teaching

I go for refuge to the Sangha, the taught

/\

I take refuge in the Buddha

I take refuge in the Dharma

I take refuge in the Sangha

/\

I have taken refuge in the Buddha

I have taken refuge in the Dharma

I have taken refuge in the Sangha

/\

THE THREE PURE PRECEPTS:

Cease to do harm.

Do only good.

Do good for others.

BODHISATTVA VOW:

However innumerable all beings are,

I vow to lead them all.

However inexhaustible my delusions are,

I vow to extinguish them all.

However immeasurable the Dharma teachings are,

I vow to master them all.

However endless the Buddha’s Way is,

I vow to follow it completely.

SVA HA!

ARTICLES @ orderengagedbuddhists.com: Order of Engaged Buddhists

The Last Words Of Christ

A Day Of Right Speech

Virtual World Of Buddhism

Spring For Change

Why Buddhism?

Rev. David Xi-Ken Astor – OEB Prior

Rev. David’s Altar Buddha

Walking meditation at Place of Peace Temple, from the Furman Univ video. Eubanks Sensei, Ven. Wayne, Ven. David.

  • About EDIG
  • EDIG MARKETPLACE
  • BUDDHIST TOOLBOX
  • MEDIA REVIEWS – Books and more
  • INTENTIONAL PRACTICE
  • JATAKA TALES AND PARABLES
  • PLACES OF INTEREST
  • Sutra & Dharma Seeds
  • THOUGHT FARM
Blog at WordPress.com.

Pragmatism, Pluralism and Practice

DHARMA WINDS ZEN HERMITAGE - (DWZH)

Ermitage Vents du Dharma (Namur, Belgium)

Shambhala Online

Pragmatism, Pluralism and Practice

The Buddha Center

Pragmatism, Pluralism and Practice

Order of Engaged Buddhists

A contemplative teaching Order

Buddhism now

Welcome to Buddhism Now an online Buddhist magazine, giving advice on how to practise Buddhism

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: